Welcome to Trophy Pizza
At Trophy Pizza, we celebrate the art of pizza-making with passion and creativity. Nestled in Cincinnati, our pizzeria offers a laid-back atmosphere perfect for groups and even welcomes your furry friends. We pride ourselves on our classic offerings, from the heartwarming Margherita Pizza to customizable half-and-half creations, ensuring there's something delectable for everyone. Our fresh ingredients shine through every dish, enhanced by house favorites like our cheesy calzones. With outdoor seating options that keep you comfortable year-round and a variety of refreshing drinks, Trophy Pizza is not just a meal—it's a memorable experience filled with flavor and warmth.
Trophy Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
My husband and I went here a few weeks ago and I cant believe I didnt write a review for it. This got a fantastic ride up in the Cincinnati Enquirer about it being the best New York style pizza in Cincinnati and that is accurate. We were ...
Excellent NY style pizza! Had a white slice, pepp slice, gramma slice, and pepp gramma slice. Took meatballs and cheese cake to go. The gramma pizza has a great chew comfort food all the way. The white slice was exactly what I hoped it ...
For a genuine taste of New York pizza, your search ends here. This is unequivocally the finest NYstyle slice in Cincinnati, filling a void that the city has long felt. Jim and his dedicated team have crafted an exceptional pizzeria. Highly recommended.
9.210 This is the real deal. As close to New York pizza by the slice as one can get without going to New York. The pepperoni slice had an excellent crispness to the dough with that signature little droop towards the end when you fold it. ...
Excellent place to dig into an authentic NY style pizza. Everything about this pizza is amazing. Dont hesitate to try it. The 20 pizzas will last you 34 meals usually and the leftover slices are good even 2 days later! Great service, ...
We stumbled in here for a quick lunch and were blown away by immaculate hospitality, and incredible pies. Rico was such a great guide to help us pick out what was great. We had pepperoni with hot honey. My 12yearold went with Plaehn ...
I stopped for lunch. Customer service was great. I got the sausagepepperoni and the chicken bacon ranch. It was the best Ive had in Cincinnati very flavorful. I always wanted to try New York style pizza but never been to New York. Will return.
I really wanted to try this place after seeing photos of the pizza. My wife and I love NY style pizza. She got the Margarita pizza in the photos. It looks great but it was undercooked in the center and overcooked at the crust. It was the ...
Location
-
10325 Reading Rd Cincinnati, OH 45241 United States Hotline: (513) 769-1111
Welcome to the delicious realm of Trophy Pizza, your go-to destination for extraordinary pizza experiences right in Cincinnati. Nestled at 10325 Reading Rd, this vibrant eatery is not just about feeding your cravings; it’s about celebrating the art of crafting the perfect pie. With a hip atmosphere and the perfect setting for groups—complete with outdoor seating options, including heated and covered areas—Trophy Pizza combines comfort and charm in every bite.
Trophy Pizza shines brightly with an extensive menu, serving both classic and specialty pizzas that will tantalize your taste buds. You can’t go wrong with their classic offerings like the Plain Cheese Pizza, crowned with rich red sauce and fresh, whole milk mozzarella. For something with a twist, try their Margherita Pizza, which features the perfect harmony of fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil. Each classic pizza is customizable, allowing you to tailor your experience by adding your favorite toppings.
If you’re in the mood for something unique, dive into their specialty pizzas. The Peppery Pig Pizza combines ricotta with caramelized onions, prosciutto, and arugula for a savory explosion. Meanwhile, the White Hot Pizza has gained a loyal following, blending pepperoni, capicola, and ricotta, all drizzled with hot honey—a perfect balance of sweet and savory that keeps you coming back for more.
But pizza isn’t the only star of the menu. Don’t miss the house-made meatballs, a delightful concoction of beef, pork, veal, and ricotta, artfully spiced and served in a rich red sauce topped with freshly grated Parmesan. They’re not just a side; they’re a highlight in their own right!
Convenience is key at Trophy Pizza, where you can enjoy their wonderous offerings by ordering delivery or takeout. They also accept reservations, making it an excellent spot for family gatherings, nights out with friends, or a laid-back first date. Plus, if you’re a dog lover, you can bring your furry companion along to enjoy the ambiance with you.
With its approachable yet delicious food, friendly service, and inviting atmosphere, Trophy Pizza stands out as more than just a pizza joint. It’s a celebration of taste, community, and the joys of dining together. Call (513) 769-1111 to reserve your spot or start planning your next delicious meal!
